“Party is the madness of many, for the gain of a few.”
– Alexander Pope
The aim of the primary election process is to allocate party delegates in each state to their chosen candidates before national conventions. This is where winning nominees are declared. It is a race for delegates, not votes. These elections draw mostly dedicated party junkies. And after the last GOP primary, when Donald Trump won the nomination, it was a dear in the headlights for the Grand Old Party. How did this happen? How could a real, true red-blooded American businessman invade the spotlight on the GOP’s stage? How could so many party members choose someone they had been trying to bury since their first debate? How could so many followers vote against the establishment candidates? This was their choice. America decided to nominate their candidate, not a party hack.
Our Constitution does not mention political parties. And this was not an accident. James Madison wrote “political parties are a dangerous vice that taint public administration.” George Washington warned against the “baneful effects” of political parties and their “insinuation” into democracy. But by 1796, two political parties emerged: the Democratic Republican party led by Thomas Jefferson and the Federalist Party led by Alexander Hamilton. Although they have changed names, platforms and even ideologies many times through evolution, two parties have run our country since 1796.
In 1796, members of Congress met informally to choose presidential nominees. This caucusing system lasted three decades. By 1824, national nominating conventions replaced the state “King Caucus.” State party bosses hand-picked delegates who would vote "correctly" at the convention. But this ultimately became an issue within the parties themselves. And by the end of World War II, states supported reforms that permitted partisans within the states to select convention delegates in primary elections scheduled before the general election.
“For a people that invented the modern political party, we have been strangely reluctant to take pride in our handiwork.”
– Clinton Rossiter
Political parties at every level of government choose their nominees through primaries. That's the most cardinal decision a party can make since all organization's most important decisions should be made by members of that organization. Primaries are closed or open with a few independent. In open primaries, a voter casts their vote for either party. In closed primaries, voters only vote within their registered party. Independent voters aren't allowed to cast a ballot. And in a blanket primary, anything goes. And these open and blanket primaries have become a pain in the rear-end for party purists.
“If I could not go to heaven but with a party, I would not go there at all.”
– Thomas Jefferson
Not only did Trump’s nomination, a virgin pedant among political candidates, rattle the cages of the GOP, it shocked the left worse than 6,000 volts from an execution chair. For years, party primaries were the glue that unified party direction for administrative election cycles. Candidates were invited that they felt fit the mold of their current docket and govern within the established traditions of their agenda and not stray far from the party reservation.
“A party is the vanguard of a class. Its duty is to lead the masses, not merely reflect the average political level of the masses.”
– Vladimir Lenin
Last presidential election was a wake up call for the left that the Clinton establishment’s mix of socially inclusive rhetoric and neoliberal economics is a weak response to xenophobic populism. Like all failed attempts to secure the White House, they retooled for the midterms and dethroned the GOP. But the GOP learning curve is stuck in aftershock and they learned nothing from what happened to propel their angry party members to surf the title wave of Trump’s victory in 2016.
Political parties have been dictating law in America so long people think we can’t have law without them. That’s not the way our founders saw it. This was an invented concept by feuding factions at our first Congress. Joining a political party is like joining any good ol' boys club. If you wish to be a member, you play by their rules or don’t play at all. And for decades, the left has played by different rules than the GOP. Winning elections by voting for the most undesirable candidate in the GOP primaries. Since they hand-pick their nominees four years in advance they can do this.
“Switching parties just before a primary undermines the principle of having party primaries.”
– Rick Reynolds
There has been a standing argument against closed primaries claiming they are not constitutional because they are limited to party members. But those that claim this fail to cognize, political parties are “private clubs” open to all who wish to join. And they are unconstitutional and not recognized as a part of making law in any government. All laws pertaining to political parties are made to control them. These laws are made by each party by their members.
“A lot of lip service gets paid to being honest, but no one really wants to hear it unless what's being said is the party line.”
– Colin Quinn
The Constitution guarantees us the right to vote in general elections since that is where we choose who represents us. This does not extend to primary elections to determine nominees. It’s a mistake to treat primaries the same way as general elections. A party is not a government and considering them as such is problematic. They are organizations, with leaders and members. Their decisions should be left to the members only. Your rights aren’t violated if you can't vote in a primary.
“It’s uncivil to vote for anyone in any party that doesn’t care about sharing and caring.”
– Hillary Clinton
Political scientists refer to political parties as "utilities" since they serve to determine who they wish to run for office to represent them. If you want to vote in their primary, they can make you become a member. Since they are open to public membership, they cannot discriminate who may join them. But voting in general elections is a constitutional right guaranteed to every qualified adult citizen.
Mark Twain wrote, “The man behind the party is more important than the party.” If the GOP wants to clean up its act, it must have closed primaries everywhere. With the growing importance of independent voters, it is paramount the GOP gives them the type of candidates they want to vote for. Die-hard Republican activists fed up with establishment GOP nominees picked Trump against all party odds. He was the candidate the independents wanted also and he won the election hands down.
“We share one heart, one home, and one glorious destiny.”
– Donald Trump
America was the first country founded on an idea birthed under the cloak of enlightenment thinkers such as Ben Franklin, John Locke, Thomas Jefferson and Thomas Paine. Political thought during The Age of Enlightenment was based on the natural rights of man, not regime power. It marked the rise of modern political ideologies and independence of self decision and self rule. That’s why no political parties were factored into our Constitution. But since we couldn’t live without them, they are our problems to control.
“The mind once enlightened cannot again become dark.”
– Thomas Paine
The GOP can no longer afford to permit leftists to pick their candidates for them.
“If a political party does not have its foundation in the determination to advance a cause that is right and that is moral, then it is not a political party; it is merely a conspiracy to seize power.”
– Dwight D. Eisenhower